Best Drugstore Eye Cream: 20 Options in 2019

selective focus of blue eyed person

The best drugstore eye cream can give any expensive eye product a run for its money.

Contrary to popular belief, cheap doesn’t always mean low-quality. When it comes to skincare, you can always find a good product that won’t break the bank.

The secret lies in knowing your skin and what types of skin actives you can use to address your particular skin problems.

There’s no single best drugstore eye cream that will work for every person. But with patience and the right information, you will find the best drugstore eye cream that’s right for you.

How to Find the Best Drugstore Eye Cream

eye cream

Image via flickr

Skincare is confusing enough. But caring for the skin in your eye area? That can bring up a lot of questions with no clear answers.

Before you start trying to look for the best drugstore eye cream, here are some of the most frequently asked questions about eye creams and, finally, some clear, definitive answers for them.

Do I really need to use eye cream?

via giphy

The short answer is yes. Eye cream is essential.

The skin around your eyes is thinner than the skin on the rest of your face. It’s more delicate and sensitive, which means that the products you use on the rest of your face may be too strong to use for the eye area.

Eye creams are formulated specifically for the most common skin problems that occur around the eyes.

For example, those dark undereye circles don’t show up anywhere else on your face. Fine lines, wrinkles, and crow’s feet also need gentler doses of moisture than the rest of your face usually gets.

Most face moisturizers come in thick, heavy formulations. It’s not much of a problem when used elsewhere, but when used for the eyes, they can increase fluid retention and make your eyes look puffy.

Also, many moisturizers contain other actives that are too harsh for the eye area. If you insist on using face moisturizer as an eye cream, make sure it doesn’t contain any of these ingredients. You also want to use a fragrance-free moisturizer to prevent it from irritating the eyes.

Who needs to use eye cream?

via giphy

Most people think they have to reach a certain age before they have to start looking for an eye cream. The truth is you need to start using eye cream the moment you start using moisturizer for the rest of your face.

If you have dark undereye circles, puffy eye bags, and crow’s feet, then you need to find the best drugstore eye cream you can get and start treating your eye area, fast!

If you currently don’t have these problems, good for you. But don’t think you have to wait for the first wrinkle to appear before you start looking for an eye cream.

For treating tired-looking eyes, prevention is always better than cure.

What ingredients do I need to look for in eye cream?

ingredients of eye cream

Image via unsplash

The best drugstore eye cream brands typically carry a medley of active ingredients that work to reverse aging and improve the appearance of the eye area.

When shopping for an eye cream, look for at least one of the following ingredients:

For plump, elastic skin

Scientific research has long proven retinol to be an effective anti-aging ingredient. As a derivative of Vitamin A, retinol stimulates skin cell turnover and encourages the production of collagen. This helps to strengthen skin while keeping it soft, smooth, and supple.

For bright, radiant skin

Vitamin C plays an important role in the production of collagen. It’s also a powerful antioxidant that protects the skin from sun and environmental damage. Vitamin C is a chemical exfoliant that sloughs off dark skin cells to help lighten the undereye area. If you have raccoon eyes, look for an eye cream that contains Vitamin C.

For richly hydrated skin

Keep lines and wrinkles at bay with hyaluronic acid. This potent moisturizer can hold more than 1,000 times its weight in water. It draws moisture to your skin like no other ingredient to deliver the hydration your skin needs to feel soft and smooth.

For smooth undereye skin

Using a caffeine-infused eye cream will help constrict the blood vessels in the eye area. This minimizes blood buildup, which contributes to the dark, puffy, undereye bags you typically get when you don’t get enough sleep.

How do I apply eye cream?

via giphy

A little goes a long way when using eye cream. Apply a pea-sized amount to the tip of your ring finger and dab it gently on the eye area. Do not rub or pull on your skin.

Apply along the orbital bone, which is around an inch from the lash line. You don’t need to go too close to your eyes.

Also, pat some eye cream along the bottom of your eyebrows and on the side of your eyes, where fine lines and wrinkles tend to develop.

Use eye cream in the morning before you go out and in the evening before going to bed. When using in the morning, let the eye cream soak in before applying makeup.

How We Reviewed

Not all eye creams are the same. To find the best drugstore eye cream, we took a careful look at their active ingredients.

Some eye creams are better suited for reducing fine lines and wrinkles. Others are designed for undereye circles and puffy eyes. And others still are best at reducing sunspots and blemishes.

We also read plenty of reviews by real people who used these eye creams. By looking at their experiences, we were able to come up with the best drugstore eye cream options for specific skin problems.

20 of the Best Drugstore Eye Cream Options

After hours of research, we have narrowed down our list of the best drugstore eye cream brands to the following.

1. Olay Age Defying Classic Eye Gel

No products found.

Olay is no doubt a household name in skincare, and for good reason.

The Olay Age-Defying Classic Eye Gel has Vitamin C and caffeic acid, two antioxidants that work together to reverse the signs of sun damage. It also contains soothing witch hazel and cucumber extract.

This satiny-smooth eye cream absorbs easily into the skin. It’s particularly amazing for dry skin thanks to the presence of panthenol, which helps with puffiness by reducing water retention while improving the skin's moisture barrier to remove wrinkles and fine lines.

Use in the morning and evening for best results. It’s light enough so you can use it underneath your makeup and rich enough to deliver intense moisture overnight.

2. Cetaphil Hydrating Eye Gel

No products found.

When you’re looking for deep hydration, the Hydrating Eye Gel by Cetaphil could be the best drugstore eye cream for you.

This nourishing eye cream has the consistency of a gel so that it absorbs quickly into the skin without leaving a sticky residue. At the same time, it works like a cream to lock in moisture and help your skin look fresh, youthful, and radiant.

Its star ingredient is hyaluronic acid, but it also includes a plethora of powerful antioxidants and plant extracts.

If you’re bothered by dark undereye circles, this eye cream has licorice extract to strengthen the skin and protect it from sun damage.

It also contains niacinamide, a powerhouse skincare ingredient proven to deliver multiple benefits. For the eye area, niacinamide can even out the skin tone and reduce fine lines and wrinkles.

3. Neutrogena Healthy Skin Eye Firming Cream

No products found.

Most eye creams take a few weeks before you start seeing their effects. But if you can’t wait that long, use the Neutrogena Healthy Skin Eye Firming Cream.

Do you have a big day ahead and you’d rather not have dark undereye circles get in the way? This cream has optical light diffusers that instantly reduce the appearance of raccoon eyes.

It also contains other ingredients that work in the long run to increase moisture and firm up the skin around your eyes. These include panthenol and an antioxidant complex that includes vitamins A, C, and E.

To combat fine lines and wrinkles, this eye cream contains alpha hydroxy acids (AHA). AHA is a powerful exfoliant that sheds off dead skin cells to reduce the appearance of fine lines, wrinkles, and age spots.

Just keep in mind that AHA increases sensitivity to sunlight. If you’re using this in the morning, make sure to layer it under sunblock.

4. L’Oreal Paris Skincare Dermo-Expertise Eye Cream

No products found.

Do your eyes need a daily dose of hydration? The Dermo-Expertise Eye Cream by L’Oreal Paris takes care of that.

This is a lightweight, non-greasy eye cream with a gel-like consistency that can be used for all skin types.

It contains hyaluronic acid to make the skin around your eyes look plump and supple. It also includes caffeine to address those puffy bags and dark circles under the eyes.

For makeup lovers, you can also use this eye cream to gently remove eye makeup at night.

5. Olay Regenerist Retinol Eye Cream

No products found.

The combination of retinol and niacinamide in the Olay Regenerist Retinol Eye Cream packs a powerful punch.

Retinol is the holy grail of anti-aging ingredients. It boosts collagen production to diminish fine lines, wrinkles, and crow’s feet.

Niacinamide is another top-brass skin active. It helps the skin build keratin, treats hyperpigmentation caused by sun exposure, and rebuilds the skin’s lipid barrier. Like retinol, niacinamide also encourages collagen production.

5. Olay Regenerist Retinol Eye Cream

No products found.

The combination of retinol and niacinamide in the Olay Regenerist Retinol Eye Cream packs a powerful punch.

Retinol is the holy grail of anti-aging ingredients. It boosts collagen production to diminish fine lines, wrinkles, and crow’s feet.

Niacinamide is another top-brass skin active. It helps the skin build keratin, treats hyperpigmentation caused by sun exposure, and rebuilds the skin’s lipid barrier. Like retinol, niacinamide also encourages collagen production.

6. e.l.f. Illuminating Eye Cream

No products found.

Say hello to illuminated eyes with the e.l.f. Illuminating Eye Cream.

This light, non-greasy eye cream penetrates quickly into your skin, leaving it soft and supple without the heaviness that often goes with rich formulas. It’s so light you can even use it under makeup without worrying about piling.

It’s specifically made to soothe and moisturize the eye area with the help of skin-repairing jojoba oil and the de-puffing power of cucumber extract.

7. RoC Multi-Correxion 5-in-1 Eye Cream

No products found.

Some people only have one or two skin problems to deal with. But what about when you’re dealing with not just two or three but the whole host of skin problems that commonly happen around the eyes?

The solution is the RoC Multi-Correxion Eye Cream. This 5-in-1 eye cream is designed to target all major eye area problems. That includes discoloration, sagging, dull tone, dryness, and wrinkles.

You don’t have to go looking for an eye cream that addresses crow’s feet and a separate cream for depuffing eye bags and dark circles. It’s all available for you in a single tub.

8. Garnier SkinActive Clearly Brighter Tinted Eye Roller

No products found.

The Garnier SkinActive Tinted Eye Roller comes in a clever packaging. The roller bottle ensures you never have to dip your fingers in the product while giving the eye area a nice, quick, refreshing boost. For some extra-cool de-puffing power, you may even want to keep it in the fridge.

This tinted eye cream not only hydrates. It also contains squalane to regulate oil production for well-balanced skin. Vitamin C brightens dark spots while caffeine reduces puffiness in the morning.

It can take a few weeks to see results, so while you’re waiting, you can use this tinted eye cream as your go-to undereye concealer.

9. Besito Anti-Aging Eye Cream

No products found.

Make your eyes look less tired with this clinically proven formula from Besito.

This anti-aging eye cream uses a combination of antioxidant-rich oils, collagen-boosting peptides, and skin-healing allantoins to lighten undereye circles, de-puff saggy eyes, and smooth out lines and wrinkles.

It also includes a dose of Vitamin K, which is used to reduce blood buildup in the tiny veins under your eyes and further improve dark circles and eye bags.

This product has a light but creamy consistency that lets it seep into the skin without leaving a trace. Use it under your makeup in the morning or as an overnight hydrating mask.

10. Eucerin Q10 Anti-Wrinkle Face Cream

No products found.

Your body naturally produces a powerful antioxidant called Coenzyme Q10. It works to destroy free radicals that cause the signs of aging, including fine lines, wrinkles, and crow’s feet.

As you get older, the body loses its ability to create Q10, but that doesn’t mean you can no longer use this antioxidant to treat the wrinkly skin around your eyes.

Enter Eucerin Q10. This simple anti-wrinkle cream replenishes your skin’s diminishing supply of coenzyme Q10. It also contains Vitamin E and beta carotene, two antioxidants that neutralize free radicals and protect your skin from damage.

It’s sold as a cream for the entire face, but it has a clean, fragrance-free formulation that makes it gentle enough for the eye area.

This face cream is rich and thick. It’s best used as a night cream.

11. Burt’s Bees Eye Cream for Sensitive Skin

No products found.

If your skin flares up at the slightest bit of any new product, you may want to try Burt’s Bees Eye Cream for Sensitive Skin.

This is one of the best drugstore eye cream options for people who badly need moisture without the redness or irritation that sometimes comes with experimenting with new products.

It’s made mostly of natural ingredients, with cotton extract that helps reduce the effects of harsh soaps and cleansers.

It also contains fermented rice extract, which is chock-full of antioxidants that minimize fine lines and tighten pores.

For tired eyes, it has soothing aloe vera that also helps decrease puffiness and improve moisture.

Use this cream every morning to perk up your eyes. It’s also good to use as a night cream.

12. LilyAna Naturals Eye Cream

No products found.


Heal, repair, and calm your eye area with the LilyAna Naturals Eye Cream.

With rosehip oil as the main ingredient, this eye cream delivers potent antioxidants that protect the skin from further damage while regenerating healthy, new skin cells.

Whether you’re dealing with dry, wrinkly skin or dark undereye circles, this rejuvenating eye treatment is your lifesaver. It firms, hydrates, lifts, and brightens your delicate eye area without causing redness, swelling, or irritation.

It’s gentle enough for the eye area but still powerful enough to use for the face, neck, and décolletage.

13. Baebody Eye Cream

No products found.

The Baebody Eye Cream is like whipped cream for the eyes. It goes on smooth like silk and feels rich like velvet.

The presence of hibiscus extract brightens a dark undereye area by gently exfoliating dead skin cells and speeding up cell turnover.

Combine this with rosehip oil, nature’s anti-aging superstar, plus a slew of moisturizing essential fatty acids, and you have a potent mix of ingredients that addresses virtually all skin problems for the eyes.

Plus, did we mention it’s paraben-free and cruelty-free?

14. Organys Eye Cream

No products found.

If you’re looking for the best drugstore eye cream to do it all, look no further. The Organys Eye Cream has everything you’re looking for.

Its pro-collagen peptides increase the natural collagen levels in your skin to iron our lines, wrinkles and crow’s feet.

To reduce dark circles, it uses soya-based peptides that boost blood circulation. These work with caffeine to minimize blood buildup and de-puff the undereye area.

It also has Vitamin C and a variety of fruit acids to peel away dead skin cells and generate brighter younger-looking skin.

Lastly, you get supreme moisturization with hyaluronic acid to keep the skin soft, smooth, and hydrated.

What more could you ask for?

15. Hada Labo Tokyo Age Correcting Eye Cream

No products found.

The Tokyo Age Correcting Eye Cream from Hada Labo uses simple ingredients to address the multiple signs of aging and fatigue.

The Japanese brand’s eye cream uses hyaluronic acid to deliver long-lasting moisture and deal with crepey undereye skin. It contains hydrolyzed collagen that absorbs into the skin to eliminate lines and wrinkles. Both work together to make your skin look plump and soft.

It also includes a dash of pink silk tree bark extract to boost the formation of collagen and elastin and protect existing skin proteins. If you're tired of being teased for your raccoon eyes, pink silk tree bark can help with that.

16. Burt’s Bees Renewal Smoothing Eye Cream

No products found.

Another winner for the natural beauty crowd is the Burt’s Bees Renewal Smoothing Eye Cream.

This hydrating eye cream is powered by hibiscus, apple, and a fruit acid complex.

Together, these ingredients work to break down dead skin and increase cell turnover to eliminate fine lines and wrinkles and brighten dark spots under the eyes.

17. Kleem Organics Anti-Aging Eye Cream

No products found.

Working hard and sleeping late can take a toll on your eyes. If you adore living life on the fast lane but can’t stand the saggy bags and dark circles that go with it, here’s Kleem Organics to the rescue.

This eye cream contains a concentrated infusion of hyaluronic acid, amino acids, and caffeine to address multiple signs of aging. That includes dull and wrinkly skin, tired and puffy eyes, and dark undereye circles.

You also get a boost of antioxidants from plant stem cellsgreen tea, and Vitamin E to further stimulate collagen production and create new skin cells.

18. ArtNaturals Anti-Aging Set

No products found.

The ArtNaturals Anti-Aging Set is not a single eye cream but a trio of scientifically proven skin actives in separate bottles.

The first bottle contains hyaluronic acid.

The second bottle is a Vitamin C serum that targets sun damage and treats skin discoloration. This bottle also includes moisturizing jojoba oil, collagen-boosting gotu kola, and soothing aloe vera.

Finally, the third bottle contains a retinol cream that’s proven to diminish fine lines and crow’s feet.

All these work together to soften, hydrate, and plump up the skin around the eyes to make you look like you always have a good night’s sleep.

19. The Ordinary Hyaluronic Acid 2%

No products found.

When you want a simple, fuss-free solution to your eye problems, go for The Ordinary Hyaluronic Acid 2%.

It’s a water-based formula that delivers intense hydration without the greasy mess that’s left behind by oil-based moisturizers.

It also contains anti-inflammatory pantothenic acid, which stimulates the skin’s ability to heal.

The Ordinary Hyaluronic Acid 2% is best used for treating parched, crepey undereye skin.

20. Queen Bee Naturals Best Eye Balm Peeper Keeper

No products found.

For that sought-after slept-all-night-look long, keep Queen Bee Naturals Peeper Keeper at hand.

It contains an array of natural ingredients packed with antioxidants, essential fatty acids, and skin-nourishing nutrients. These include jojoba oil, olive oil, sunflower oil, coconut oil, and meadowfoam seed oil.

It also contains beeswax, which forms a natural protective barrier on the skin to prevent moisture from seeping out and toxins from leaking in.

This all-natural organic eye cream is best used for preventing fine lines and wrinkles. It’s also helpful in treating skin that's thirsty for moisture.

​​What’s the Best Drugstore Eye Cream for You?

eye cream

Image via pexels

Finding the best drugstore eye cream involves a lot of trial and error.

If you’re lucky, the first eye cream you pick up from the drugstore may be the only eye cream you’ll use for life.

Most of us aren’t as fortunate. It may take a lot of patience and maybe even a few breakouts before you find the right eye cream for you.

Don’t be discouraged. It'll all be worth it once you find the best drugstore eye cream that’s right for you.

Have you found your holy grail eye cream? What is it and how does it work for you? Let us know in the comments below.

Featured Photo by Amanda Dalbjörn on Unsplash


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here